Patricia Cartwright
3/26/2017 03:25:40 pm
It seems that even the explanations that researchers provide for altruism can be egotistic. With kin selection, we have the desire to increase the odds that our blood will be passed on to future offspring because we perceive our ingroup members as an extension of ourselves. Likewise, although not tangible, there are neurological, pleasurable rewards that we can feel for helping others. Therefore, we may help others because it makes us feel good which is inherently selfish. Lastly, the social norms seem to motivate helping behavior because of the fear of censure, loss of status or favor, or the potential for reciprocity. Is there any empirical support that shows people help without the slightest egotistical motive?
Hailey Ripple
3/27/2017 08:05:50 pm
I agree with what Patricia said about the explanations or definitions that some researchers give to altruism appearing to lean more towards egoism. The definition from Wilson, 1984 mentions something we discussed in class about "pure altruism". Based on this wording, it makes me think that this researcher believes that altruism exists to a degree in combination with some level of egoism and that "pure altruism" would be a truly selfless act. I think that this alone shows that the way you define altruism makes a huge difference in whether or not you believe it exists.
Amanda
4/2/2017 08:48:08 pm
I also agree with Patricia and I also agree with Hailey's statement. I think that the wording in the explanations and definitions behind altruism have some egoist undertones. In your prosocial behavior section, you quote that people with altruism will "never ever demand anything in return...". I feel the words "never ever" are a bit of a stretch, I don't believe in people "never ever" not doing anything. I feel like even through an act of kindness it can be unconsciously insinuated that something should be given in return.
Ashley Coleman
4/17/2017 09:20:29 am
The quote from Wilkson (1984) is really interesting, as it suggests that altruism can be accidental. What do you think? Can an action be altruistic without altruistic intent? Comments are closed.
|
AuthorsThis site is a collaborative effort of the Spring 2017 Advanced Social Psychology graduate seminar at Mississippi State University.. Archives
April 2017
Categories
All
|